Newly released data from TransferWise reveals that there were higher than the usual exchange rate markups by PayPal or their banks in March.
This was soon after Singapore’s DORSCON levels were upgraded from yellow to orange in February and led to more stringent social distancing measures. The first three months of 2020 have seen a surge in online shopping, with the trend continuing (source: The Straits Times) as circuit breaker measures were implemented in early April.
At the same time, a comparison of the most popular international shopping currencies from Singapore showed that the exchange rate markups charged by PayPal across USD, GBP, EUR, AUD, HKD and CNY peaked in March at 4.80%, falling to 4.54% in April.
OCBC exchange rate markups increased to 1.26% in April, with UOB peaking in March at 1.23%. DBS’s exchange rate markups dropped from a peak of 0.94% in October 2019 to 0.90% in January, which it has maintained.
Exchange rate markup on USD, GBP, EUR, AUD, HKD and CNY
These currencies were chosen based on the popular e-commerce sites Singaporeans shopped from and the popular currencies they paid in.
More using online services to send and spend money Findings from mobile app market intelligence software Apptopia showed that the use of money transfer apps, including TransferWise, increased worldwide by nearly 11% over the past two and a half months, and is a direct result of the lockdown measures which shifted activity online.
Meanwhile, data from personal holders of the TransferWise Platinum debit Mastercard showed that online shopping spend amongst TransferWise customers in Singapore increased from 52% to 76.2%
TransferWise Singapore card spend for personal users
How to shop online from overseas retailers without the fees
Watch out for two fees that your card provider and PayPal may charge when shopping from international retailers:
- Foreign transaction fee – Even if you pay in Singapore dollars, most banks charge what’s known as a foreign or international transaction fee if the retailer is outside of Singapore. If you have a Visa, Mastercard or American Express credit/debit card with any of the big banks, you’ll be hit with these international transaction fees which shows up on your statement after you purchase.
- Currency conversion fee – While some debit or credit cards won’t charge a foreign transaction fee, a hidden cost you won’t know about until it happens is the currency conversion charge. Credit and debit card issuers will often charge you a transaction fee of 3-3.5% of your purchase in order to convert your Singapore dollars into the currency used by the retailer, while PayPal includes their own inflated exchange rate at the checkout.
Transferwise’s conversion fee is typically between 0.35% and 2.22%, lower than the industry average. Alternatively, given that the TransferWise debit card allows customers to hold 40+ currency balances customers can pay in the local currency wherever possible to save on currency conversion fees.
Here are two examples of the TransferWise debit card in action:
1. Animal Crossing: New Horizons, a Nintendo Switch game, is priced at USD59.99 and bought using the TransferWise debit card will cost SGD 85.29 (based on the mid-market exchange rate which TransferWise uses and can be seen on XE.com).
Meanwhile, at their current rate, using PayPal will cost SGD87.69, based on their own conversion rate (which is the combination of exchange rate the service provider uses and their currency conversion processing fee). That’s SGD2.40 more than using TransferWise.
2. A pair of women’s yoga leggings from Lululemon’s Hong Kong online site priced at HKD880 and bought using the TransferWise card will cost SGD161.35. With Paypal, it will cost SGD167.71 – an extra SGD6.36.
Price comparison when shopping with PayPal and TransferWise
For more information on spending with the TransferWise debit card, visit here.
Generally, providers give better exchange rates and charge smaller fees for higher-value transfers, this approach helps to reduce the risk of inflating the cost of using the relevant provider, in fact, it may show a better rate for the relevant providers than what they may actually be.
